BunnyfootBunnyfootBunnyfootBunnyfoot
  • Our services
  • About us
  • UX training
  • Our clients
  • Blog
  • Contact us
    Home Brain Bites: 2 Minute Insights Because nobody’s baby is ugly … should designers test their own stuff?

    Because nobody’s baby is ugly … should designers test their own stuff?

    By Cathy Carr | Brain Bites: 2 Minute Insights | 0 comment | 1 April, 2015 | 0

    It’s far from the ideal situation, because when you are the creator (mother) of a design (baby) it can be hard to admit that it is … in fact … UGLY!
    You’ve probably heard the saying ‘the lawyer who represents himself has a fool for a client’; you may also be aware of the ethical policy followed within the medical profession ‘that surgeons should not operate on a family member’. So the question ‘should developers and designers test their own creations?’ We think it’s never a good idea …
    Don’t get us wrong, we understand the need for this when working within small start-ups or a downsizing UX team as it’s highly likely that you’d be asked to both create and test your own designs due to lack of resources. However, in this situation any form of testing (even guerilla testing) would be beneficial to development of the design rather than the alternative … no testing, which, as a usability consultant, is not a viable alternative.

    Pitfalls of testing your own designs

    • Designers are emotionally invested in their designs, therefore it can be hard for them not to take the feedback personally and begin to defend the design/decision making
      • in order to get relevant and reliable results that we can confidently act upon it is imperative that the moderator is as objective as possible
    • If users are made aware that it is your design that they are testing, or that you work for the company that provided the service, they are unlikely to be as honest and forthcoming with their feedback (especially negative feedback) as you may need them to be
      • providing customers with a neutral environment where they can confidently talk freely and openly about their experiences is crucial to the feedback that you obtain
    • It can be difficult for designers to admit defeat and throw the design away if need be, to start again … instead designers who are emotionally invested with the creation are more likely to try and patch the flaws within the original design
      • delivering bad news and knowing when to quit and start again can often make more economical sense than pursuing on with the original design solution
    • Designers are susceptible to employing tasks that focus almost exclusively on their own pet features, rather than on goals that users really want to accomplish
      • the scenarios/user tasks that users are asked to conduct during the testing sessions should be representative of the key tasks that users conduct with the service when ‘in the wild’.

    At Bunnyfoot, our consultants conduct a range of services, including testing and creating interaction designs. Often we conduct user tests for our clients’ creations and at other times we test our own Bunnyfoot creations, e.g. wireframes, lo-fi prototypes and fully functioning sites.
    However the philosophy within Bunnyfoot is we do not moderate user tests on designs that we have created ourselves. Instead, we use another consultant, who has no emotional investment in the design, to conduct the actual user testing sessions. However, the creator(s) are always present to observe the live testing sessions to enable them to see first-hand how their designs are received by real users, allowing iterative changes to be made between sessions.

    Why use an external agency (like us!)

    • It provides a fresh pair of eyes, not clouded by frequent or constant exposure to your company’s processes/language (jargon). Sometimes you can be so close to your own designs that you can no longer ‘see the wood from the trees’
    • They can be impartial to the design (no emotional investment), therefore we are able to deliver results neutrally, as findings that simply translate customer’s experiences (not influenced by internal politics etc)
    • We see beyond the limitations of the current platform/service, provide more blue sky/long term recommendations
    • External consultants have experience and skills, varying in breadth and depth, over a range of different industries. They are therefore able to translate this knowledge and learnings to the design where applicable
    • Testing in impartial surroundings makes it easier to gather participants’ thoughts, experiences and opinions as they are not influenced by the environment
    • At Bunnyfoot we have our own participant recruitment service, with a pool of target users ready to attend the testing sessions.

    Ultimately any test is better than no test

    If you can afford it, it’s better to use a dedicated usability specialist to perform your projects usability activities while you and your team observe. But ultimately any kind of testing with real users is hugely beneficial to the development of a design.

    Want to learn more?

    • Training Course: User Testing
    Usability testing

    Cathy Carr

    More posts by Cathy Carr

    Related Posts

    • ‘AR’-commerce – a novel and functional shopping experience

      Jan 26, 2021

      In my previous post I wrote about how augmented reality (AR) is changing our daily activities like watching sports, studying or navigating around. This post is an overview of AR-powered e-commerce trends. AR applications in e-commerce have been around for... Read more

    • AR isn’t mainstream… or is it?

      Jan 7, 2021

      For many years augmented reality (AR) has been portrayed as the next big thing. Apple CEO Tim Cook has voiced his excitement about AR technology on numerous occasions. In 2017 Apple developed their AR developer framework ARKit, opening the door... Read more

    • It’s time to act – reducing the carbon in your digital footprint

      Sep 28, 2020

      Change is upon us There is no denying that we face an environmental crisis. The scientific community has made it clear that human activities are warming the planet and degrading our environment to the point where, if no action is... Read more

    • What is the best Service Design tool?

      Sep 16, 2020

      Design Thinking and/or Service Design tools and methods are all high on the agenda for many companies, especially in this time of uncertainty we live in when we have to re-think many of our services and how our customers/users interact... Read more

    Leave a Comment

    Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published.

    NextPrevious

    Recent Posts

    • ‘AR’-commerce – a novel and functional shopping experience January 26, 2021
    • Webinar: UX & Sustainable Service Design January 12, 2021
    • AR isn’t mainstream… or is it? January 7, 2021
    • What makes an effective UX Consultant? Bunnyfoot speaks to UX Usability Podcast December 11, 2020
    • What’s in a name? User Experience and UX Design vs. Design Thinking November 24, 2020

    Categories

    • Brain Bites: 2 Minute Insights
    • Brain Feasts: Longer Reads
    • Brain Licks: 10 Second Wisdom
    • Bunnyfoot Updates
    • Content: White Papers, Research Reports and More
    • Events
    • News and Announcements
    • Talks and Presentations
    • Tools and Resources
    • Uncategorised

    LONDON

    4th Floor
    54 St John’s Square
    Farringdon
    London
    EC1V 4JL

    Tel: 0207 608 1670

    SHEFFIELD

    The Old Chapel
    8 Mortimer Street
    Sheffield
    South Yorkshire
    S1 4SF

    Tel: 0114 478 2950

    OXFORD

    Boston House
    134 Downsview Rd
    Wantage
    Oxfordshire
    OX12 9FF

    Tel: 01235 606 140

    Cyber Essentials (PLUS) Logo
    • Copyright Statement
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Training Course Terms & Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Jobs
    © Bunnyfoot Ltd 2020 | Bunnyfoot is part of the Sideshow Group
    • Our services
    • About us
    • UX training
    • Our clients
    • Blog
    • Contact us
    Bunnyfoot
    We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
    Privacy PolicyREJECTACCEPT
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are as essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled

    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

    Non-necessary

    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.